Nimbyism is one thing, existing residents objecting to a proposal that will affect their peace and quiet, but having the audacity to move into an area and then complain about what you find there is quite another. The diaspora from the city to the countryside is fraught with difficulties. People who are quite content to put up with the hum of traffic and the rattle of trains while living in an urban setting suddenly seem shocked when they find that the countryside is not the tranquil Elysium they had imagined it to be and that the soundscape is full of mooing cows, noisy cockerels, and the peal of church bells.
The French courts have been plagued with cases in which irate newcomers have sought to put an end to alleged noise pollution caused by a host of animals, even frogs croaking in a pond and noisy cicadas going about their cicadian business. Not any more, though.
In a piece of legislative breath air, that puts our own moribund parliament to shame, the French parliament has just passed a law that puts an end to such nonsense, giving the courts the authority to strike out such cases. As the justice minister, Éric Dupond-Moretti, observed, “those who move to the countryside cannot demand that country people who feed them change their way of life,”
Well said.